I found some more information on the mystery “Tolner Padlock”. It appears it has nothing to do with Wm. Wilcox, it must have just happened to appear directly above Wilcox’s section of the catalog, leading to my confusion.
The lock is sometimes referred to as a “Vulcan Padlock” or Acorn Padlock, due to some of them being marked with “Vulcan Hardware Co” and “Patent Acorn”. There are others marked “Meyer & Eiffler”, “A. Hammacher”, and “Tollner & Hammacher” (certainly the reason for the typo’d listing as a Tolner (one ‘L’) Padlock . Looks like these companies were predecessors to Hammacher & Schlemmer who were initially hardware dealers in NYC. They are in fact a push-key padlock model which predates the 1870+ “pancake” models based on Miller’s design
I’ve come across several patents for similar locks, but they all come after the publication of this catalog (1864).
Patents: 72378 (1867), 102810 (1870), and I suspect others probably earlier.
I’m still researching all of this, but wanted to post an update.
